9 Comments
User's avatar
Anonymous's avatar

AI is not the problem, traditional education is. AI just makes it more evident. Long before AI, schools and degrees were already drifting toward irrelevance (see: https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2014/03/05/the-problem-with-lecturing).

We need to deprecate an obsolete paradigm based on memorization and acquisitive success. Human short-term memory is relatively poor, by the time we're adults we forget much of what we learned in school. We should embrace AI as a tool to access knowledge instantly, freeing us to focus on important skills like learning how to learn, problem-solving, critical thinking, emotional intelligence, etc.

Expand full comment
Sherry Ning's avatar

+1. I think AI reveals how arbitrary a lot of tests are

Expand full comment
Jim ciccarelli's avatar

On point!,teach in schools how to use AI from as early as practical.

Expand full comment
Jim ciccarelli's avatar

Sorry, you are so wrong on this. I usually love your stuff and I'm calling bs.

AI is not going away, our goal is to embrace and shape. It has the potential to give us a 30 hr work week.

I lived long enough to have heard the "no calculators " nonsense.

Show your work. Use every tool.

Expand full comment
LEDpolicy's avatar

The fire you speak of—the temple of difficulty—is real. But what burns most isn’t friction.

It’s simulation.

Academia became hollow not just from ease, but from performing difficulty without transformation.

Smoothness isn’t just aesthetic. It’s institutional anesthesia.

If we want to become human again, we don’t need more lectures.

We need to stop mistaking rigor for ritual.

Struggle means nothing unless it cuts.

Let the system collapse. Let the student remember what it means to become.

Expand full comment
Tom White's avatar

LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE THE BACK!

I wrote something similar: “AI didn’t start this. But it will finish it unless we step in.

In Ulysses, James Joyce wrote: “Think you’re escaping and run into yourself. Longest way round is the shortest way home.”

We must choose the “longest way round” because meaning is neither fast nor viral nor optimized.”

https://www.whitenoise.email/p/when-the-internet-was-for-people

Expand full comment
Ankur Handa's avatar

Having read many of your essays, I can't help but notice that Santiago often shows up in many of them. You must love The Alchemist a lot :)

Expand full comment
Tubagus Gleamen Bastzara Putra's avatar

We need to learn to focus more on Principal learning, rather than Agent learning.

We need to be independent thinkers, rather than stuck in known system.

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

We need difficulty!! I loved this piece Sherry!

Expand full comment